The Best Eye-Makeup Removers That Take Off Even Your Longest-Wearing Products

Best Overall

Take the Day Off cleanser balm has reached holy-grail status, and the eye-makeup remover version of the trusted balm is bae. Seriously. You no longer need to shy away from waterproof mascara on the off-chance it won't budge before bed. A few drops of Clinique's removal liquid is all it takes for eye makeup to completely dissolve.

More: Makeup Wipes Ideal for Evening Removal

Best Budget Buy

Garnier's innovative solvent is as much of an essential nighttime makeup remover as it is an awesome refresh in the morning. Featuring a unique Micellar technology that alleviates the day's makeup — sans the need to rub your eyes clean — the water-based cleanser is gentle over skin, and it leaves eyes moisturized and makeup-free.

Best Splurge

Try this dual-action makeup remover that wipes your eyes clean of stubborn makeup while special moisturizing elements leave your skin feeling refreshed. To start the process, gently shake to activate the first part of the bi-phase technology. The lipid phase eliminates makeup, followed by the water phase that conditions the skin.

Sephora's best-selling eye-makeup remover gets rid of even the most stubborn leftover eyeliner. Its waterproof formula, safe for contact wearers and those with sensitive eyes, even features a lash-strengthening complex that's rich in flavonoids and olivewood extracts. Sign us up!

Glossier's makeup removing cleanser catapulted to cult status pretty quickly. Join the bandwagon by gently massaging the gel-like formula over lids, around the general eye area, and gradually making your way over the entire face. Infused with five essential skin conditioners and gentle cleaning agents, the solution guarantees a bare face without any unnecessary irritation.

One of Kim K's must-have makeup removers, this liquid formula from NARS features cucumber and chamomile. It's an extremely mild remover, so there's no need to rub incessantly. Gently dab with a cotton ball around the eye area and over lids for a refreshing wash that leaves eyes completely clean.

Mary Kay products are top-notch, so you know from the name that this is one to trust. The hypoallergenic, oil-free formula removes any and all eye makeup as gently and effectively as possible.

Some removers take a toll on our eyes, but Neutrogena's Eye Makeup Remover Lotion is safe to use daily. In addition to ridding your eyes of those long-lasting liners and mascaras, the formula replenishes your skin without the irritating red splotches.

Eye- and lip-product stains are arguably the trickiest to wipe away, but with Shiseido's Instant Eye and Lip Makeup Remover, you can kiss liner tattoo and lingering hues goodbye. Formulated with the sugar alcohol xylitol, this removal oil requires minimum application for maximum results.